Proverbs 26:1-12
Do you see a man who is wise in his own eyes?
Proverbs 26:12
There is more hope for a fool than for him.
Most of the proverbs in today’s reading disparage fools in one way or another. It is easy to nod our heads in agreement. We can all point to examples of people who have acted foolishly, and we can see how these proverbs fit all those fools.
But then we come to verse 12. If you are anything like me, your first inclination is to keep nodding in agreement. “Yep,” we say, “that’s right.” And all the while we are, of course, thinking of ourselves as wise — at the very least, wiser than all those fools — and so we are in danger of being this one that is worse than a fool.
Frankly, this strikes me as a bit of a Catch-22. If you are wise, then you naturally recognize wisdom in yourself, but any attempt to deny your own wisdom (i.e., to not be wise in your own eyes) would be foolish, so you must recognize your own wisdom, but that is bad, so… Gotcha!
Clearly, that “Catch-22” interpretation of this verse is off-target. By the “Catch-22” logic, the author would even be condemning himself, because he clearly considers himself to be wise as he dispenses these proverbs. We are consistently called to be wise and to exercise wisdom. And part of wisdom is to recognize wisdom wherever one finds it, even in oneself. So simply recognizing wisdom within oneself cannot be what the author means by “wise in his own eyes”.
So what does he mean? This verse is a stern warning against pride, against thinking too highly of ourselves and our own judgment and not highly enough of others. That does not mean that we should always favor someone else’s opinion over our own, but we must lay aside our own biases and search for truth. In the end, we must always understand that the ultimate source of wisdom is God Himself, and we must surrender to Him.